When Sarah Snook opens the front door in All Her Fault and realises the woman inside has never heard of her son, your heart stops with hers. It’s one of those moments that burrows under the skin – a universal dread so instantly recognisable it feels real. That’s because, in a way, it is. The series, adapted from Andrea Mara’s 2021 novel, was sparked by a very real incident that unfolded one unremarkable afternoon in suburban Dublin.
Is All Her Fault Based On A True Story?
Long before it became a high-stakes thriller starring Sarah Snook, Dakota Fanning and Jake Lacy, All Her Fault began with something mundane: a mother collecting her child from a playdate.
In 2015, Irish writer Andrea Mara drove to what she thought was a friend’s house – only to find the home empty, the family long gone. For a few excruciating seconds, no one answered her knock. There was no sign of life. The creeping thought – what if something’s happened? – took hold. Moments later, a neighbour appeared to explain that the family had simply moved. The panic evaporated. But the question lingered: how easily could a harmless misunderstanding slip into a parent’s worst nightmare?
That flash of maternal terror became the seed of Mara’s novel – and now, Binge’s newest psychological thriller. “It all ended quickly in real life,” Mara has said, “but the fear – that primal, gut-level fear – stayed with me.”
What Happens To Milo In All Her Fault?
The show follows Marissa Irvine (Snook), a successful lawyer and mother whose picture-perfect life shatters when she discovers her young son Milo has vanished during what should have been an ordinary playdate. The stranger at the door has never heard of Milo. The house is not what it seems. From there, secrets begin to unravel – about the neighbours, the parents, and even Marissa herself.
Joining Snook is Dakota Fanning as Jenny Kaminski, another mother drawn into the unfolding chaos, and Jake Lacy as Marissa’s husband Peter, whose calm exterior hides layers of deceit. What starts as a straightforward missing-child mystery spirals into a twisted web of guilt, grief and buried truth.
The story isn’t just about the abduction – it’s about the crushing weight of modern motherhood, the invisible labour of keeping everyone safe, and the uncomfortable question of how well we really know the people around us.
What Has Author Andrea Mara Said?
Mara has often said her thrillers grow from “what if” questions. What if a playdate turned sinister? What if a neighbour wasn’t who they seemed? What if the person you trusted most was the one to fear?
For parents, these hypotheticals feel painfully close to home. “We hand our children over to others – teachers, coaches, other parents – every single day,” Mara wrote in The Irish Independent. “How do we know what’s safe? And why do we worry more than ever?”
That modern anxiety – the endless calculus of risk and responsibility – pulses through every frame of All Her Fault. Even as the show unfolds into shocking twists (no spoilers here, but prepare to gasp), it never loses sight of that original spark: a mother’s fleeting, primal panic at the thought of losing her child.
While the adaptation stays faithful to the novel’s spine-tingling premise, it expands the emotional terrain. Mara, who served as associate producer, has said that beneath the thriller beats, the story is “hugely about female friendship.” The bond between Marissa and Jenny evolves from suspicion to solidarity – a nod, perhaps, to the real women who rallied around Mara as she juggled writing, motherhood, and life’s everyday chaos.
“Even if the kidnap element is fictional,” she wrote on Instagram, “the friendship element is absolutely true.”
It’s a rare kind of thriller that allows women to be messy, fearful, loyal, and brave all at once – not just victims or villains, but fully human.
Watch All Her Fault on Binge now
Related stories
Native ad body.
Native ad body.
Native ad body.
